Skip to main content
Learning Center

Insurance

The Top 10 Insurance Mistakes Patients Make

7 min read

Summary

Before treatment, verify referrals, authorization, network status, medication coverage and costs. A doctor’s recommendation does not automatically mean your plan will pay.

The biggest mistake patients make is assuming that because a doctor recommends a medication, surgery, or procedure, their insurance will automatically cover it.

A treatment can be medically necessary and still require additional steps before the insurance company will pay for it. Understanding referrals, prior authorization, medical necessity, network rules, and prescription coverage can help patients avoid delays, unexpected bills, and preventable denials.

Here are 10 critical mistakes every patient should know how to avoid.

Don't panic. Don't assume. Verify. A recommendation, scheduled appointment or authorization is not a guarantee of payment. Do not delay emergency care to complete insurance checks.

1. Assuming a specialist appointment doesn't require a referral

Common mistake

Some insurance plans, especially HMOs, require a referral from a primary care provider (PCP) before a patient sees a specialist.

What can go wrong: The specialist visit may be denied or paid at a lower level, depending on the plan and circumstances.

What to do:

  • Check whether your plan requires a referral.

  • Ask your PCP to submit it to the correct specialist.

  • Confirm the referral is approved, if required, and valid for the correct provider, service, and dates.

  • Ask whether follow-up visits require a new referral.

2. Confusing a referral with prior authorization

These are two different requirements.

  • Referral: Permission or direction to see a specialist, when the plan requires it.

  • Prior authorization (PA): The insurer's review of a proposed medication, procedure, test, or treatment before it is provided.

What can go wrong: A referral may be on file, but the surgery, MRI, injection, or medication may still lack required authorization.

What to do: Ask the ordering provider and insurer separately whether a referral and prior authorization are required. Obtain the authorization reference number when available.

3. Assuming the doctor's recommendation guarantees coverage

A physician's recommendation does not automatically satisfy every insurance coverage rule.

What can go wrong: The insurer may request medical records, evidence of conservative treatment, imaging results, or documentation that the proposed treatment meets its medical-necessity criteria.

What to do:

  • Ask what clinical documentation the insurer requires.

  • Make sure records and test results are submitted.

  • Ask whether the insurer requires step therapy, a second opinion, or other prerequisites.

  • If denied, request the specific reason and appeal instructions.

4. Failing to verify in-network status for everyone involved

A hospital may be in-network while a particular specialist, anesthesiologist, laboratory, or imaging provider has different network arrangements.

What can go wrong: Higher out-of-pocket costs or unexpected bills, subject to applicable federal and state protections.

What to do: Verify the facility, surgeon, ordering physician, and other known providers. For planned procedures, ask who will provide anesthesia, imaging, pathology, and laboratory services.

Emergency care and certain services at in-network facilities have additional protections under the No Surprises Act; don't assume every out-of-network bill is automatically valid.

5. Assuming a prescribed medication is automatically covered

A prescription from a licensed provider does not guarantee that the medication is on the patient's formulary or covered under the patient's pharmacy benefit.

What can go wrong: The medication may require prior authorization, step therapy, quantity-limit approval, a preferred alternative, or a specialty pharmacy.

What to do:

  • Check the current formulary and drug tier.

  • Confirm whether the drug is covered under the pharmacy benefit or medical benefit.

  • Ask whether a generic, preferred alternative, or exception is available.

  • Have the prescriber submit the required clinical documentation.

Important: Do not abruptly stop a prescribed medication because of a coverage problem. Contact the prescriber or pharmacist about safe next steps.

6. Scheduling a procedure before confirming required authorization

Patients may assume that if the hospital schedules the procedure, all insurance requirements have been satisfied.

What can go wrong: The authorization may be missing, pending, denied, or issued for the wrong procedure, facility, provider, or date.

What to do: Before a planned procedure, ask the ordering office and facility to verify authorization status. Confirm the approved service, location, provider when applicable, and validity dates.

A scheduled appointment is not proof of authorization.

7. Accepting “it's covered” without asking what that means

Coverage depends on the plan, service, network, deductible, copayment, coinsurance, and applicable exclusions.

What can go wrong: A patient hears that a service is covered and assumes it will cost nothing.

What to do: Ask the insurer:

  • Is the service a covered benefit under my specific plan?

  • Is prior authorization required?

  • Does my deductible apply?

  • What copayment or coinsurance should I expect?

  • Are there exclusions, limits, or site-of-service requirements?

Request a reference number for the call. A coverage estimate is not necessarily a guarantee of payment.

8. Not following the insurer's required treatment sequence

Some plans require patients to try preferred medications or less intensive treatments before approving a more expensive option.

What can go wrong: A requested medication, imaging study, or procedure is denied because the insurer says a required step has not been completed or documented.

What to do: Ask whether step therapy, conservative treatment, specific diagnostic tests, or documented treatment failures are required. If a step is medically inappropriate, ask the prescriber about an exception and supporting evidence.

9. Ignoring denial letters, deadlines, or requests for information

A denial is not always the end of the process. Some problems result from missing documentation, incorrect coding, an unmet plan requirement, or an administrative error.

What can go wrong: The patient misses an appeal deadline or fails to supply evidence that could change the decision.

What to do:

  • Obtain the denial notice and identify the exact reason.

  • Find the appeal deadline and submission instructions.

  • Ask the provider for supporting records or a medical-necessity letter when appropriate.

  • Keep copies, submission confirmations, call reference numbers, and dates.

If care is urgent, ask whether an expedited appeal or urgent review is available.

10. Failing to review the Explanation of Benefits (EOB)

An EOB is generally an insurance processing statement, not a bill. It explains how a claim was processed and what the insurer says may be owed.

What can go wrong: A patient pays too soon, overlooks a denial, misses a duplicate charge, or fails to question a claim that was processed incorrectly.

What to do:

  • Compare the EOB with the provider's actual bill.

  • Review the service date, provider, billed amount, insurer payment, adjustments, and patient responsibility.

  • Check whether the claim is pending, denied, or processed.

  • Contact the insurer and provider about discrepancies before paying a disputed amount.

Keep an eye on appeal deadlines and billing due dates while the issue is being reviewed.

The Murray Standard takeaway

Patients should not have to become insurance experts just to receive appropriate care. But learning to ask the right questions before treatment can make a real difference.

Remember these three questions:

  • Does my plan require a referral?

  • Does this medication, surgery, or procedure require prior authorization?

  • What else must be completed for my plan to cover it?

One important distinction: authorization is not an absolute guarantee of payment. Coverage still depends on the plan's terms, eligibility, the service actually performed, claim processing, and other applicable requirements.

That is why The Murray Standard's patient-navigation approach matters: understand the problem, identify the requirement, confirm the next step, and keep a record.

Key takeaways

  • A referral and prior authorization are separate requirements.
  • A recommendation, appointment or authorization does not guarantee payment.
  • Verify the provider, facility, service and authorization dates with your specific plan.
  • Do not abruptly stop medication because of a coverage problem; ask your prescriber or pharmacist.
  • Review denial notices and deadlines, and compare the EOB with the provider bill.

Common questions

Does a referral also authorize my treatment?

Not necessarily. Ask the insurer and ordering office separately whether both a referral and prior authorization are required.

Does authorization guarantee payment?

No. Payment still depends on plan terms, active eligibility, the service actually performed, claim processing and other applicable requirements.

What if a medication is not covered?

Ask your prescriber, pharmacist and plan about the formulary, alternatives, required authorization or an exception. Do not abruptly stop a prescribed medication.

What should I do with a denial or an EOB?

Read the reason, check appeal and billing deadlines, and ask which records are needed. An EOB is not a bill; compare it with the provider statement before paying a disputed amount.

Helpful resources

A verse for encouragement

“Wisdom is supreme. Get wisdom. Yes, though it costs all your possessions, get understanding.”

— Proverbs 4:7

Scripture is offered for encouragement and reflection and is not a substitute for professional medical, legal, financial, or healthcare advice. Verses are quoted from the World English Bible, a public domain translation.

This article is educational information about how the healthcare system works. It is not medical, legal, or financial advice, and it does not describe any specific person’s case. Always confirm details with your insurer, your provider, or an official government source.

What to do next

Related reading

Build an appeal letter

Organize your questions and prepare a draft to review before sending.

Open tool

Last reviewed: Not yet recorded

Report an error